The chief of industry trade body the Remote Gambling Association today told MPs the government’s regulation and tax plans for egaming were “gambling with our future”.
Clive Hawkswood made the comment while giving evidence to the Culture Media and Select Committee on the government’s draft bill, where the RGA argued the government’s proposed place-of-consumption regime would ultimately saddle legitimate operators with a huge extra tax burden which would increase the attractiveness of betting on unlicensed sites for British consumers.
“The trouble from our side is that, is this a government gambling with our future? If this goes well, well, excellent. If it goes wrong, once we have lost out, the government can look at it again in a few years, and the businesses are ruined.”
Hawkswood also had to face accusations from Lib Dem MP John Leech that the RGA’s opposition to the proposals on behalf of its members was rooted in tax avoidance. “Is there any difference between Starbucks not paying their taxes and online arms of high street bookmakers choosing to move their businesses elsewhere to avoid paying that tax?”
With the RGA earlier raising the current absence of any enforcement mechanisms against illegal operators in the bill, Leech followed up by asking: “Would you accept if we get the enforcement right so you are not competing against unlicensed companies, it would be perfectly reasonable for you all to pay the tax that is due?”
Hawkswood however responded by arguing that enforcement mechanisms, particularly alongside a high tax rate, “don’t work. Someone will come along that won’t take a Gambling Commission licence, that you can’t stop, and they will just take market share from the companies.” RGA European advisor Wes Himes also provided evidence of how reliance on ISP blocking and financial transaction blocking had proved ineffective across the EU, a point also raised in Paddy Power’s written submission.
MPs however seemed unphased by Hawkswood highlighting HM Treasury’s “conservative” estimate that “the goverment would only capture 80% of the market” with its proposals, Labour MP Paul Farrelly arguing that: “Isn’t the reality that if you take 90% [as in Denmark] then you take a view of proportionality on what you do, depending on how much is leaking to whom?”
Farrelly’s view was supported by chair John Whittingdale, who said: “There would be some people who would be stupid to place a bet on a site based in Central America, but the vast majority of people are not that stupid. You will capture the overwhelming majority of the market. There may be a small number who go onto an illegal site, but if you make this as difficult as possible, surely you will have achieved the objective.”
Gala Coral however criticised this assumption in its written submission: “Whilst HMT may be happy to collect 70% / 80% of a tax take they do not currently have, driving 20%/30% of the market underground in poorly regulated environments will have serious consequences for consumer protection, protection of the young and vulnerable in society advertising (online) standards.”
The operator also observed of the draft that “the reasons stated for introducing point of consumption regulation are not supported by the evidence”, concluding “that the only reason to bring in the new legislation is to impose point of consumption taxation.”
Ladbrokes and William Hill both called in their submissions for the eventual tax rate to be set at 5% of gross profits, in Ladbrokes’ words “to maximise the level of compliance among operators”, with Paddy Power advocating for “an absorbable rate (5-8%).” The Irish operator said: “This encourages operators to remain within the boundaries set by the licensing regime without being overly disadvantaged compared to non-compliant operators.”
Article written by Stephen Carter

This story is sponsored by Paddy Power






